In partnership with
Hey honeys and hustlers,
Today, I’m bringing you some words from Daniel Hunter, the writer behind the IndieThinkers newsletter. Daniel and I had a great conversation on Substack live last year, and it’s been a joy watching him build Tech Twitter and his newsletter. They are both decidedly anti-AI slop, so if you’re in the tech space, I think you’ll enjoy them. Here’s his take on Substack increasingly becoming a social media platform, and how it really compares to text-forward social media platforms.
P.S. Stay til the end for our first community spotlight of the year!
Twitter has owned the internet’s town square for over a decade. News always breaks there first. Companies announce launches. Movements begin, and memes are born. Every major tech company maintains a presence, and startups spend a ton of cash securing the best handles for their brands.
This doesn’t really happen anywhere else.
Handles on Twitter are so valuable now that there’s even a new marketplace for them.
You might hate the toxicity. You might despise the owner. You might be exhausted by misinformation, as am I. But if you work in tech or media, you’re probably still there, even if you’re not an active contributor.
Twitter is, and will always be, the internet town square.
When Google ships a new model, they announce it on Twitter. When a founder wants feedback, they post on Twitter. When journalists need to know what people are talking about, they check Twitter. The platform has become infrastructure.
But the town square is loud. Everyone can see what’s happening. Information moves fast. You bump into people you weren’t expecting. Sometimes you witness something important. Sometimes you just get yelled at.
You can’t think deeply in the town square. Everything you say is a performance. The format pushes you toward quick takes. And there’s this anxiety about who’s watching.
Substack is different, and it should focus on staying that way.
Substack is the coffee shop.
People are more vulnerable. They share personal struggles. Half-finished ideas. They’re less afraid and more honest. The long-form format filters for readers who’ll invest time. However, Substack has drifted away from this core value prop.
Twitter and Substack solve opposite problems. Twitter: “I need to know what’s happening right now.” Substack: “I need to think through something that matters.” Threading out a long essay on Twitter feels awkward. You’re still performing. Using Substack for breaking news feels weird with this half-baked trending feature.
Screenshot of the trending section on Substack.
I wish Substack would stop doing this.
A city needs both town squares and coffee shops. So does the internet.
The space shapes the thinking. Town squares produce quick reactions optimized for spreading. Coffee shops produce reflection, complexity, and vulnerability.
Zuckerberg created Threads and tried to be Twitter with better moderation. LinkedIn tried to be a professional Twitter with longer posts. Both struggled because they wanted the town square reach with the coffee shop depth. You can’t have both. The town square works because it’s open and chaotic.
The coffee shop works because it’s intimate and curated.
Online discourse will never consolidate into one platform.
Substack should take note.
Thanks for reading! 💌
Daniel Hunter is a tech writer building community through his newsletter, IndieThinkers, and Tech Twitter. Check out his work!
🚀 Community Spotlight
Demetrius Bagley is the founder of Black Podcasting Awards and the writer behind the daily Black podcast recommendation newsletter, One Black Podcast a Day. He recently shared an incredible article on the top 10 headlines about Black podcasts in 2025 that was a joy to read and ponder. He is currently raising money to keep the Black Podcasting Awards running, so donate and submit your podcast today!
Open to: podcast submissions.
Want to be featured in this newsletter? Add your name to the Creator Database or nominate someone by replying to this email! I’d love to share your story and what you’re working on with our community!
This post is supported by our sponsor.
Banish bad ads for good
Your site, your ad choices.
Don’t let intrusive ads ruin the experience for the audience you've worked hard to build.
With Google AdSense, you can ensure only the ads you want appear on your site, making it the strongest and most compelling option.
Don’t just take our word for it. DIY Eule, one of Germany’s largest sewing content creators says, “With Google AdSense, I can customize the placement, amount, and layout of ads on my site.”
Google AdSense gives you full control to customize exactly where you want ads—and where you don't. Use the powerful controls to designate ad-free zones, ensuring a positive user experience.
If you’d like to sponsor editions of Please Hustle Responsibly and reach {{active_subscriber_count}} marketers, creators, and entrepreneurs, you can respond to this email or visit our media page below.