|
Hey honeys and hustlers,
I genuinely wonder if Twitter is looking at Substack and asking itself how it fumbled a huge head start. There’s a little graveyard on the internet for newsletter platforms that seemed like a good idea at the time. TinyLetter is there. Revue is there. And somewhere nearby, I imagine a very stressed creator is trying to remember where they saved their subscriber export. The funny thing is, newsletters didn’t die with them. Quite the opposite. We’re still showing up in each other’s inboxes, writing about everything from the future of media to what we ate for lunch. The appetite for email was never the problem. So why did some newsletter hosts disappear while others thrived entirely on the premise of being the best place to send an email? I think the answer has less to do with email itself and more to do with what happens when a platform tries to be everything to everyone.
A tale of two shutdowns
TinyLetter was wonderfully simple. You wrote a letter. People subscribed. You sent the letter. No elaborate creator dashboard demanding that you also build a funnel, launch a course, and consider starting a small community. Mailchimp acquired TinyLetter in 2011 and shut it down in February 2024. In its explanation, Mailchimp pointed to a shift in priorities toward marketing tools for small businesses. TinyLetter may have been beloved by writers, but it no longer fit neatly into its parent company’s plans.
I can’t help wondering what TinyLetter’s founder thinks when looking at Buttondown today. Buttondown has carved out a place for people who want an email-first tool without necessarily adopting a new social network. That doesn’t mean TinyLetter would have survived independently, or that simplicity alone is a business model. But it does suggest that the desire for a quieter, more focused way to publish never disappeared. The little newsletter could have a future, even if TinyLetter itself didn’t.
Then there’s Revue, which Twitter acquired in 2021 and shut down in January 2023. On paper, the pairing made sense: writers already had audiences on Twitter, and a newsletter gave them another way to reach those people. Twitter had a head start on connecting short-form conversation to longer-form writing and email. Placing a banner to sign up for your newsletter on your profile felt like a huge feature at the time that everyone was looking to capitalize on, myself included, even though I didn’t have the first clue what to write about. Looking at Substack now, I do wonder how much of an opportunity Twitter left on the table.
But having a head start is not the same as having a reason to stay in the race. Twitter was built around a feed. Revue was built around delivering something to an inbox. Those things can work together, but they don’t automatically share the same priorities. I have no idea what happened in Twitter’s internal meetings, but my suspicion is that building a truly great email platform would have required sustained investment in a product that also sent people away from the feed. For an advertising-driven social platform (at least at the time, before Twitter’s new CEO implemented a subscription option), that tension may have been the straw that broke the camel’s back. This is just my theory about the incentives, or lack thereof, for a social platform to invest in email.
The everything-app dilemma
None of this means adding features is bad. Sometimes a new feature genuinely saves you from juggling five subscriptions, three browser tabs, and one increasingly fragile automation held together by hope (literally me with my beehiiv subscription). One company that comes to mind is Riverside. It began as a tool I used for recording remote interviews, and it has expanded into video editing, podcast publishing, and livestreaming. That can be convenient! But the reason it stands out to me, and likely other paying users, is still the quality of its remote recording experience, which is head and tails above any other tool. The other features are nice, and likely serve a key part of their paying user base. But Riverside must still deliver on a quality recording experience, or the new features will remain unused.
I think about newsletter platforms the same way. Substack’s strength isn’t just that it can send an email. It’s the network around the writing: writers finding other writers, readers finding their next favorite publication, and conversations happening on the platform itself. That discovery is valuable. It’s also a reason for Substack to keep building places for people to spend time, from Notes to video and podcasts. Substack’s subscription model ties its business to writers earning from paid subscribers. It has also been expanding sponsorship tools, including announcing podcast sponsorship capabilities. Those are different revenue streams with different incentives, but the bigger picture is clear enough: the more a platform’s business depends on an ecosystem of creators and readers, the more reason it has to make that ecosystem a place people want to stay.
That can be great for discovery. It can also mean your newsletter is sharing a home with a lot of other things competing for your reader’s attention, like Substack’s release of a new feature, Lists. The question isn’t whether social features are inherently good or bad. It’s whether they’re helping you build the kind of relationship you actually want with your audience.
What survives the feature buffet?
My bet is that focused platforms like Buttondown and Ghost have a real advantage here. Not because they’re guaranteed to outlive anyone—TinyLetter is a pretty good reminder not to make that promise—but because their central value is easier to understand. Buttondown is email-first; Ghost is built around publishing, newsletters, and memberships. Neither needs to connect to a social feed to be useful to a writer.
beehiiv and Kit sit somewhere in the middle. They offer more than a place to write and send an email, with tools for growth and monetization that can be genuinely helpful to creators building businesses. I use beehiiv, so I understand the appeal of having more of that workflow in one place. Kit’s creator-commerce and automation tools serve a different set of needs. The trade-off is that more features can mean more decisions, more complexity, and more reasons to ask whether the platform is still excellent at the thing you came for.
And that’s the question I keep coming back to: What is this platform trying to be really, really good at? Not what it announced this week. Not how many shiny new features it added to justify a price increase. What job does it prioritize when resources are tight, and its business model has to make a choice? For creators, the practical takeaway isn’t to panic-migrate every time a company releases an AI button, increases its prices, or increases its revenue percentage cut. It’s to understand how your platform makes money, pay attention to what it’s investing in, and keep usable backups of your subscriber data and work. A custom domain you control can help, too. Check what actually transfers—including subscriber consent, content, and paid-subscription arrangements—before you need to move. An email list is portable in ways a social following often isn’t, but portability takes a little preparation.
And having someone’s email address doesn’t mean you own the person on the other side of it. The relationship still has to be earned with every useful, interesting message at a time. TinyLetter and Revue are gone, but the thing people wanted from them is still very much alive: a direct line between a writer and a reader.
Have you ever had to move your newsletter because a platform changed or disappeared? Hit reply and tell me what you learned.
Here’s a message from the folks who help keep the lights on.
Stop feeding the feed.
You’ve put in the work to build an audience. But when the only way to reach your fans is through a social feed determined by algorithms, the platform decides who sees what you make next.
beehiiv gives you the tools to reach your audience directly. On their all-in-one platform, you can turn followers into subscribers, grow your newsletter, and connect it all to your community or podcast. Stop chasing virality on platforms you can’t control. Build a stronger, more sustainable business on beehiiv.
If you’d like to sponsor editions of Please Hustle Responsibly and reach 2,243 marketers, creators, and entrepreneurs, you can respond to this email or visit our media page below.

